Alt8

ALT 8 Reasons Streetcars Are Better Than Buses

on Monday, October 25, 2010 at 7:05 PM

The second round of the TIGER II grants were announced last week and there’s been an obvious bias towards streetcars. In fact, the government just gave the largest grant — $47.6 million — to build a streetcar line through Atlanta’s downtown tourism district. The project will create 930 construction jobs initially, but city officials estimate it will lead to more than 5,600 permanent jobs. So why do governments, transportation experts and riders prefer streetcars? Here are our ALT 8 reasons.

1. Most modern streetcars have a higher capacity than buses. According to Portland Streetcar Inc., “A streetcar attracts 30-50 percent more ridership than a comparable bus. It is thus plausible to assume an average 40 percent more ridership attracted to streetcar service. In other words, a comparable bus service would attract approximately 30 percent lower ridership.” Typically modern streetcars have a capacity of around 200 compared to 120 for a typical articulated bus. Which means you can move lots of riders on fewer vehicles — which leads to a more efficient use of fuel and fewer drivers to pay.

2. Streetcars attract more riders than buses. It’s largely a perception thing, but most riders prefer riding a train than the bus. A widespread disinterest or disapproval of buses usually makes people prefer the train. Also, streetcars are more comfortable than buses because they don’t jerk around as much. Steel wheels are much more pleasant to ride than tyre wheels.

3. Streetcars promote urban development. As we’ve said several times before, access to transit leads to business and economic growth. People don’t build businesses next to bus stops necessarily but trains have always lead to more real estate growth and denser communities.

4. Electric streetcars are quieter and more environmentally friendly than diesel buses. And while some buses are electric — like in San Francisco — those aren’t common at all.

5. Though streetcars require a higher initial investment in the long run they are more affordable than buses because they are easier to maintain and last longer than buses. Also, money is saved on reduced fuel costs. While buses must be replaced about every 10 years, streetcars typically last 40 years or more. Philadelphia’s SEPTA transit system is still using streetcar vehicles built in 1947.

6. Streetcars generally have a dedicated lane to themselves, so they go faster and are more likely to follow a schedule. The cars are also not dependent on traffic jams and street congestion. Also, streetcars usually stop at fewer stops making the ride more efficient for everyone.

7. Streetcars are much quieter than buses because they run on electricity. As a result, they are much less likely to cause disruptions in neighborhoods.

8. Streetcars are easier to navigate than buses. Bus routes are often confusing, but with streetcars the train tracks make for easy to follow routes.

BONUS POINT: Streetcars and more fun!

Realistically, of course, streetcars and buses compliment each other and should be used in unison to move people around.

Ami Cholia is co-editor of AltTransport. Follow her on Twitter @amicholia.

Follow AltTransport on Twitter @alttransport.

Related Stories

Comments are hidden for your protection. Click here to show them.

  • David C

    Not convinced. Possibly because I shirk at only getting one side of a discussion. Imagine the environmental scarring in laying down tracks and then discovering no one is using your service. What about flexibility? What about track and power supply maintenance? What about visual landscape impact from the overhead wires? What about the complex intersection interactions? I think giving the pros and cons is much more useful to the discussion: you may have just turned me off light rail.

  • http://alttransport.com/2010/11/transit-cuts-leads-cities-to-bus-rapid-transit/ Transit Cuts Lead Cities To Bus Rapid Transit – AltTransport: Your Guide to Smarter Ways of Getting Around

    [...] course, there are several upsides to rail: they carry more passengers, they’re more permanent, they pollute less than diesel buses, and [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus

Sign up to get AltTransport in your inbox.


The AltTransport Community

AltTransport is dedicated to giving you the latest news and the smartest analysis of the shift towards smarter and more efficient modes of transportation. We can’t do that without a community—and that means we need your help.

Are you a carbon-conscious commuter who has a smart or interesting way of getting to work every day and would like to be featured? Write us here. (We’re also interested in hearing about companies with smart transportation policies and programs.)

Should your company be in our directory of clean-transportation companies? If so, let us know.

Do you have a cleantech transportation-related company or organization that needs help with advertising, research or lead-generation? Let us know about it.

Do you have a tip or do you want to write for us? Are there topics or issues you want to see addressed on our site? Hit us here.

Our Team

Editor
Ami Cholia

AltTransport is published by Breaking Media LLC. For a full list of our sites and services, go to BreakingMedia.com.

Most Read This Week

  • No results available

Most Commented

  • None found