High-Speed Rail

Florida High-Speed Rail Would Have Made Money: DOT Report

on Wednesday, March 9, 2011 at 5:26 PM

Florida’s Governor Rick Scott rejected $2.4 billion in federal money to build a high-speed rail line between Tampa and Orlando citing potential cost overruns and low ridership. Turns out, he was wrong. A new report released by the Department of Transportation finds that the project would have made more money and carried more passengers than projected in 2009.

The Florida Department of Transportation released data today that showed that the operations would have made a surplus of $10.24 million in 2016, the first full year the trains would have run, and a $28.58 million surplus in 2026.

The line between Tampa and Orlando would have had 3.3 million riders, generating almost $63 million in ticket sales during its first year of operation in 2015-16.

The $1.3 million ridership study was done by the transportation consulting firms Steer Davies Gleave and Wilbur Smith Associates.

While Scott had originally said that he would wait for this data before he rejected the $2.4 billion in federal money granted to the state to build the $2.7 billion Tampa-Orlando phase of Florida’s project — he rejected the money on Feb. 16.

Scott claimed that he didn’t want to put Florida tax payers on the hook for cost overruns, despite being presented with a plan in which private companies would take on all costs and loses.

Republican Senator Thad Altman, who attempted to sue Scott over his legal authority to return the money said, “His conclusion was political, not based on economics, good business or even protecting the taxpayers,” Altman said. “As time passes and more information comes out, you can see the injustice that was done to the state of Florida.”

More and more it seems like Scott rushed to rejecting Florida’s high-speed rail money for political reasons. Especially since several private firms had been clamoring to bid on Florida’s high-speed rail initiative.

Ami Cholia is co-editor of AltTransport. Follow her on Twitter @amicholia.

Follow AltTransport on Twitter @alttransport.

Related Stories

Comments are hidden for your protection. Click here to show them.

  • Life vs. Death

    You all are making a big mistake going down this path. He has a very good reason for rejecting this rail. Go away now and count the blessing of you and your families here in Orlando and area. I promise you you don’t want to go here. Trust in what I am saying. This is more than the Gov wanting us to have a bit of work and a railroad. besides how can Billions and Billions be on the line for an hour drive???????????????????????????????????????????????????????

  • http://twitter.com/casperorchids William Paxson

    You all are making a big mistake going down this path. He has a very good reason for rejecting this rail. Go away now and count the blessing of you and your families here in Orlando and area. I promise you you don’t want to go here. Trust in what I am saying. This is more than the Gov wanting us to have a bit of work and a railroad. besides how can Billions and Billions be on the line for an hour drive???????????????????????????????????????????????????????

  • http://alttransport.com/2011/03/businesses-support-californias-high-speed-rail/ Businesses Support California’s High-Speed Rail – AltTransport: Your Guide to Smarter Ways of Getting Around

    [...] Wisconsin and Florida declined federal stimulus funds for high-speed rail in their states more for political reasons than business ones. All three governors claimed that they didn’t want tax payers to [...]

  • Anonymous

    Ami,
    Have you read the report?
    Your link just goes to another story that references this study.
    I think it’s a bit cavalier to criticize Scott’s decision unless you have read and analyzed the virtually impossible to find study.
    If you have a link to the study, please provide it so we can make an intelligent assessment.

  • http://alttransport.com/2011/03/obamacare-turns-into-obamarail-for-conservatives/ ObamaCare Turns Into ObamaRail For Conservatives – AltTransport: Your Guide to Smarter Ways of Getting Around

    [...] a report released by the Department of Transportation found that the project would have made more money and carried [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus

Sign up to get AltTransport in your inbox.


The AltTransport Community

AltTransport is dedicated to giving you the latest news and the smartest analysis of the shift towards smarter and more efficient modes of transportation. We can’t do that without a community—and that means we need your help.

Are you a carbon-conscious commuter who has a smart or interesting way of getting to work every day and would like to be featured? Write us here. (We’re also interested in hearing about companies with smart transportation policies and programs.)

Should your company be in our directory of clean-transportation companies? If so, let us know.

Do you have a cleantech transportation-related company or organization that needs help with advertising, research or lead-generation? Let us know about it.

Do you have a tip or do you want to write for us? Are there topics or issues you want to see addressed on our site? Hit us here.

Our Team

Editor
Ami Cholia

AltTransport is published by Breaking Media LLC. For a full list of our sites and services, go to BreakingMedia.com.

Most Read This Week

  • No results available

Most Commented

  • None found